Forum: XTM Cloud support
Topic: XTM is a murderer.
Poster: Donglai Lou
Post title: A few recommendations
[quote]XTM Intl wrote:
Dear Donglai Lou,
Thank you for your post. Please be aware that since version 7.5 XTM has a fully featured XTM Offline Editor based on Microsoft Excel. You can download the Excel form via the 'Files->Offline Translation' page. Click on the 'Generate' icon and choose 'Excel' as the file format. The XTM Offline Excel mode is much better for working in offline mode. Once you have finished translating just upload the resultant Excel file. The XTM Offline Editor requires Microsoft Excel 2007 or later versions.
Kind regards,
XTM Support Team [/quote]
Dear Sir,
First, please understand I am with you rather than simply complain about the XTM.
second, I believe you'd better create something for the translators rather than for yourself or PMs. for example, the excel file you mentioned, I did download it but found it is 150mb "huge" and slow down my system without any obvious icons to link my local TM and termbase. Thus, I closed it after 15 minutes. I am not sure how many people translate using excel.
Third, for the wordcount, once there was a 30K Chinese into English job. the client said it was only 12K, which was the analysis result of XTM. another thing is the prevailing stats model of counting words. I can give numerous samples of false results. for instance there is only one identical word in a three word segment, the result is 66% match. in a segment of 30 words, only less than 14 words are repeated, the result is as high as 73% match. (my friend gave me a formula to show how this was calculated.) I understand this is not your problem as it is a kind of "bullying and exploiting industry standard." it's hard for me to believe this will be something proposed or endorsed by real translators.
Fourth, the XTM doesn't support Chinese well. the main problem is with corrector' changes. even if the proofreader changes only one character, the whole sentence appear red. it is very time consuming and bad to eyes.
Wish XTM better and better, so our hard life could be a bit easier.
best regards,
Donglai Lou